Insights

Insights & Perspectives

Back to all articles
Finance Manager, Controller or CFO: What Does Your Business Actually Need?

Finance Manager, Controller or CFO: What Does Your Business Actually Need?

By Helen Li, FCPA · CA (ANZ)

As a business grows, financial decisions become more complex. A common question follows: should you hire a Finance Manager, appoint a Controller, or bring in CFO support?

But choosing a job title before defining the requirement can lead to the wrong solution.

A delayed month-end report, an unreliable cash forecast, and a lack of financial challenge are different problems. They do not necessarily require the same role.

Start with the finance capability your business needs, not the title you think you should hire.

Identify the Finance Capability Your Business Is Missing

Before comparing roles, identify the underlying requirement:

Capacity: More resources to complete established finance work reliably.

Specialist expertise: Targeted knowledge for a defined financial or operational issue.

Senior judgement: Stronger forecasting, commercial challenge, and financial decision support.

Leadership: Clear responsibility for finance priorities, decisions, and follow-through.

Function development: Improvements to systems, processes, controls, or responsibilities.

These needs can overlap. The priority is understanding what finance must deliver and who needs to take responsibility.

Four Questions to Compare Finance Support Options

What responsibility needs to be owned?

Does the business need advice on a specific issue, or someone responsible for leading ongoing finance decisions? A project adviser may resolve a defined problem. Ongoing leadership requires clearer accountability.

How closely must finance work with management?

Occasional technical input is different from regular involvement in hiring, investment, pricing, and business planning. The greater the decision-making responsibility, the more important management integration becomes.

How much support is needed, and for how long?

Is the requirement occasional, as-needed, transitional, or full-time? Consider both workload and business complexity. A temporary arrangement can involve substantial leadership responsibility, while an ongoing requirement does not automatically justify a full-time role.

When should the arrangement be reviewed?

Will the requirement change when a project finishes, internal capability develops, or business complexity increases? Define these conditions before choosing the engagement model.

When Does a Finance Manager, Controller, or CFO Make Sense?

Different roles can provide different capabilities, although responsibilities vary between businesses.

Finance Manager: Often suited to managing recurring finance operations, reporting, and team responsibilities.

Controller: May be appropriate where financial control, reporting quality, and operational accountability need strengthening.

Project or Interim Support: Useful for defined changes, specialist requirements, or transitional leadership.

Fractional CFO: Can provide ongoing senior financial judgement and leadership without full-time involvement.

Full-time CFO: May be appropriate when business complexity requires sustained senior leadership and deep management integration.

None is automatically the better option. Developing an existing team or improving technology may address the requirement without adding another senior role.

Choose Finance Capability Before the Job Title

The right arrangement depends on what capability is missing, who must own it, how closely finance must work with management, and how long the need will continue.

A title describes a position. It does not define whether the business has the finance capability it needs.

At L&S Group Consulting, we help growing businesses identify their finance requirements before deciding which role or support model is the right fit.

Back to all articles